Articles / Arbitration
Malaysia · 5 minute read

My contract sends disputes to AIAC. What does that actually mean?

An AIAC clause means that disputes are to be referred to arbitration. You generally cannot sue in court first. The companion article explains the limited situation in which a court case may still proceed.

AIACReferred to arbitrationNot a court claim first

At a glance

  • A clause that sends disputes to the AIAC is an agreement to refer those disputes to arbitration, not to start an ordinary court case.
  • You generally cannot sue in court first. If a court case is filed anyway, the other side can usually have it stayed in favour of arbitration.
  • The companion article explains the exception: if the other side does not object, or takes steps in the court case, the court case can proceed.
  • AIAC administers the process; the arbitral tribunal decides the dispute. The product of that process is an award.

It means the dispute is referred to arbitration

Many commercial contracts, franchise agreements, construction appointments and joint-venture documents contain a short clause near the end: any dispute is to be referred to arbitration, often “at the AIAC” or “in accordance with the AIAC Arbitration Rules”. That clause is an agreement to take the dispute out of the ordinary court list and to have it decided by an arbitral tribunal.

In practical terms, you generally cannot sue in court first. The agreed path is to refer the dispute to arbitration. If someone files a court case anyway, the other side can usually apply to stay that case and send the parties to arbitration. The companion article, “There is an arbitration clause. Can I still file a court case?”, explains that stay, and the limited situation in which a court case may still proceed — namely, if the other side does not object, or takes steps in the court case.

The product of an AIAC arbitration is an award, which can be recognised and enforced, not a casual negotiation. It is easy to sign past the clause. It is harder to unwind later.

It has to be an arbitration agreement in writing

Section 9 of the Arbitration Act 2005 defines an arbitration agreement as an agreement by the parties to submit to arbitration all or certain disputes which have arisen or which may arise between them in respect of a defined legal relationship, whether contractual or not. The agreement may be a clause in a contract or a separate agreement, and it shall be in writing.

Writing includes a signed document, or an exchange of letters, emails or other communications that record the agreement, or an exchange of claim and defence in which the agreement is alleged and not denied. A reference in a contract to a document that contains an arbitration clause can also be enough, if the contract is in writing and the reference makes that clause part of the agreement. Electronic communication can satisfy the writing requirement where the information is accessible for later reference.

If there is no such agreement, a party cannot usually be forced into AIAC arbitration merely because the other side prefers it. If there is such an agreement, a party cannot usually treat the clause as optional when a dispute later becomes inconvenient.

What AIAC is, and what it is not

The Asian International Arbitration Centre (Malaysia) is the institution formerly known as the Kuala Lumpur Regional Centre for Arbitration. From 28 February 2018, references to the KLRCA in written law and in documents are to be read as references to the AIAC. The centre administers arbitrations under its rules, maintains facilities, and, importantly, has a role in the appointment of arbitrators when the parties’ agreed method fails.

AIAC is not the tribunal. The dispute is decided by the arbitrator or arbitrators appointed for that case. Nor is AIAC a government department that “sides with” a Malaysian or a foreign party. Its function is to administer a process that the parties have agreed to use. There are also AIAC procedures for other forms of dispute resolution, including adjudication under CIPAA, which is a different statutory process and is the subject of the construction articles in this batch.

What the process generally looks like

In outline, a party starts the arbitration in the manner required by the agreement and the applicable rules, the tribunal is appointed, written submissions and evidence are exchanged, there may be a hearing, and the tribunal issues an award. The Arbitration Act 2005 supplies the legal framework when the seat of the arbitration is in Malaysia, including the appointment mechanism in section 13. If the agreed method of appointment fails, the Director of the AIAC may be asked to make the appointment, so that the process is not frustrated at the first step.

The procedure is more flexible than a full High Court trial, but it is still a formal process. There will be a timetable, a place or an online hearing, and costs — institutional administrative fees, the tribunal’s fees, and the parties’ own representation. Those costs depend on the rules, the amount in dispute and how the case is run. This article does not quote fee schedules, which change and which should be read from the current AIAC materials.

Section 8 of the Arbitration Act 2005 provides that no court shall intervene except where so provided in the Act. Courts still have defined supporting roles, for example certain interim measures under section 11, and later challenges or enforcement under the Act. The general policy is that the parties, having agreed to arbitrate, should arbitrate.

Privacy, and what not to assume

Many parties choose arbitration because the hearing is not a public gallery in the way a court trial often is. The AIAC Arbitration Rules contain confidentiality provisions, and parties commonly agree to keep the proceedings private. The Arbitration Act 2005 is not, however, a statute that should be described as making every Malaysian arbitration secret in all circumstances. What is confidential, as against whom, and with what exceptions (for example enforcement in court), depends on the agreement, the rules that have been incorporated, and the Act. It is safer to read those texts than to assume that “AIAC” means “nobody will ever find out”.

The award is meant to end the dispute

An award is binding on the parties, subject to the limited grounds in the Arbitration Act 2005 for setting aside or resisting enforcement. It is not a suggestion, and it is not the same as a mediation settlement, which exists only if the parties agree. If the contract also provides for negotiation or mediation first, those steps may have to be considered before a notice of arbitration is served. That, again, is a question of construction of the particular clause.

What to do when a dispute is looming

Read the dispute-resolution clause, the governing law, and any set of rules it incorporates, before filing anything in court or sending a formal notice. Preserve the contract, the correspondence, and the invoices or completion records that will be the substance of the dispute. As a general rule, the next step is to refer the dispute to arbitration, not to start an ordinary court case. If a court case has already been filed, or you are considering filing one, the companion article on section 10 stays is the next reading.

Sources

  • Arbitration Act 2005 (Act 646), sections 8, 9, 11 and 13, including the 2011 and 2018 amendments. The 2018 amendments recorded the change of name from KLRCA to AIAC with effect from 28 February 2018.
  • AIAC Arbitration Rules (current edition to be read for procedure, confidentiality and fees; this article does not reproduce the rules).
  • Companion article on this site: “There is an arbitration clause. Can I still file a court case?”.

General information only, not legal advice. This article does not predict the outcome of your matter. Contacting the firm does not create a lawyer–client relationship until we confirm we can act.