Articles / Construction
Malaysia · 5 minute read

What is a payment claim and a payment response under CIPAA?

A CIPAA adjudication does not begin with a notice of adjudication. It begins with a written payment claim, and then a short, strict period in which the other party may serve a payment response.

Payment claimPayment responseCIPAA

At a glance

  • A payment claim must be in writing and must include the amount, the due date, details of the cause of action, a description of the work or services, and a statement that it is made under the Act.
  • A payment response must be served within ten working days of receipt of the claim.
  • If there is no response, the non-paying party is deemed to have disputed the entire payment claim. Silence is not treated as agreement to pay.
  • The right to refer the dispute to adjudication arises only after the period for a payment response has expired.

Start here, not with the notice of adjudication

Contractors sometimes speak of “filing a CIPAA” as if the first document were a notice of adjudication. Under the Act, the first statutory document is a payment claim. Section 7(2) is clear: the right to refer a dispute to adjudication shall only be exercised after the expiry of the period to serve a payment response under section 6(3). A notice served too early can waste time and may have to be started again.

The payment claim and payment response also frame the later adjudication. An unpaid party who serves a vague or incomplete claim, and a non-paying party who serves no response, or a response with no reasons, each create problems for themselves. This article is about those two documents.

What a payment claim must contain

Section 5(1) provides that an unpaid party may serve a payment claim on a non-paying party for payment pursuant to a construction contract. Section 5(2) requires the claim to be in writing and to include four things: the amount claimed and the due date for payment of that amount; details to identify the cause of action, including the provision in the construction contract to which the payment relates; a description of the work or services to which the payment relates; and a statement that the claim is made under the Act.

Those four requirements look simple, and they are often the place where a claim is later attacked. “Details to identify the cause of action” means more than a round figure and a project name. Identify the contract, the payment clause or default provision relied on, the period of work, and how the amount is built up — for example a certified sum that has not been paid, a progress claim, a variation, or a release of retention, as the facts are. Attach the contract extract, the certificate or the breakdown, if that is how the amount is explained. The claim should also say, in terms, that it is made under the Construction Industry Payment and Adjudication Act 2012.

Serve it in a way that you can later prove. Section 38 sets out how notices and documents under the Act may be served: personal delivery; leaving the document at the usual place of business during normal business hours; registered post to the usual or last-known place of business; or any other means agreed in writing. Informal WhatsApp messages, without more, are a poor substitute for a service method you can demonstrate.

The ten working days for a payment response

Once the payment claim is received, the clock is short. Section 6(3) requires a payment response to be served within ten working days of receipt. “Working days” is a defined term in section 4; it does not mean any ten calendar days, and public holidays matter. Diary the deadline on the day the claim arrives, not a week later.

If the non-paying party admits the claim, section 6(1) requires a payment response together with the whole amount claimed, or any amount admitted. If the non-paying party disputes the claim wholly or partly, section 6(2) requires a written payment response stating the amount disputed and the reason for the dispute. A response that merely says “we disagree” or “the work is defective”, without identifying the amount and the reasons, is a weak foundation for the later adjudication response.

This is the moment to set out set-off, contra charges, defects, or a contractual defence in an orderly way, with the documents that support them. It is much harder to build a coherent dispute for the first time after the adjudication notice has been served.

What silence does — and does not — mean

Section 6(4) provides that a non-paying party who fails to respond to a payment claim in the manner provided under the section is deemed to have disputed the entire payment claim. That is the opposite of a default judgment. Not answering does not mean you have agreed to pay. It means the whole claim is treated as disputed, and the unpaid party may then refer it to adjudication.

Silence is therefore a poor tactic. It gives up the chance to admit what is due, to narrow the dispute, and to state reasons and figures that the adjudicator will later expect to see. It also leaves the unpaid party free to proceed on the full claimed amount as a disputed claim.

After the response period expires

Section 7(1) allows either the unpaid party or the non-paying party to refer a dispute arising from a payment claim to adjudication. The right is only exercisable after the section 6(3) period has expired. Section 7(3) also subjects a dispute referred to adjudication to the Limitation Act 1953, or to the Sabah or Sarawak limitation ordinances, as the case may be. A stale payment claim is not made timely merely because it is later dressed as a CIPAA claim.

The notice of adjudication, the appointment of the adjudicator, and the 45-working-day decision period are described in the companion article. They are later steps. They depend on this first paper trail being in order.

Advice for both sides of the same letter

If you are unpaid: do not send a loosely worded letter and hope it will later be treated as a section 5 claim. Prepare a claim that can be read against section 5(2) line by line, serve it properly, and diary the ten working days. If you are the employer, main contractor or other non-paying party: open the claim on the day it arrives, take the deadline seriously, and either pay what is admitted or explain, with reasons and figures, what is disputed.

CIPAA was designed to move payment disputes along. The payment claim and payment response are where that movement starts. A careful first document is more useful than a hurried notice of adjudication built on a thin letter.

Sources

  • Construction Industry Payment and Adjudication Act 2012 (Act 746), sections 4 (definitions, including “working day”, “unpaid party” and “non-paying party”), 5, 6, 7 and 38. Official text consulted from the AIAC’s published compilation of the Act.
  • Companion article on this site: “The other side has not paid for construction work. What is CIPAA adjudication?”.
  • Related case article already on this site: View Esteem Sdn Bhd v Bina Puri Holdings Bhd, on defences in a CIPAA setting.

General information only, not legal advice. This article does not predict the outcome of your matter. Contacting the firm does not create a lawyer–client relationship until we confirm we can act.