At a glance
- Against a private hospital, clinic or doctor, the usual time limit is six years, under the Limitation Act 1953.
- Against a government medical facility, the usual time limit is three years, under the Public Authorities Protection Act 1948.
- These are general rules. The exact deadline depends on the facts, including when time starts to run. Take advice early; do not wait for a complete set of records.
- A later “date of knowledge” rule in section 6A does not, on the face of the statute, extend time for a typical personal-injury medical claim.
The usual answer: six years, or three
If you are thinking about a medical negligence claim in Malaysia, a practical first question is how long you have to start it. As a general rule, the time limit is six years where the claim is against a private hospital, clinic or doctor, and three years where the claim is about treatment in a government medical facility.
The six-year period comes from the Limitation Act 1953. The three-year period comes from the Public Authorities Protection Act 1948, which in section 2(a) states the period as thirty-six months. Those are the headline rules. They are general information. The exact deadline in any matter depends on the facts, including when time starts to run, and should be checked with a lawyer early enough for a claim to be issued if that is the proper next step.
Limitation is a legal time limit for starting a court action. If a claim is filed too late and the defence of limitation succeeds, the court can dispose of the claim without deciding whether the treatment itself was negligent. A second opinion, a hospital complaint, or a complaint to a professional body does not, by itself, stop time from running.
Six years against a private hospital or doctor
A medical negligence claim against a private hospital, clinic or doctor is generally an action founded on tort. Section 6(1)(a) of the Limitation Act 1953 provides that such an action shall not be brought after the expiration of six years from the date on which the cause of action accrued.
Six years can feel like a long time. In practice it is often shorter than families expect, because the clock does not wait until a second opinion is obtained, records are complete, or a family has finished grieving. The Limitation Act 1953 applies to Peninsular Malaysia. If the matter arises in Sabah or Sarawak, the local limitation ordinances should be checked.
Three years for a government medical facility
A shorter, three-year period usually applies where the claim is about treatment in a government hospital or clinic, or about a public officer acting in the execution of a public duty. Section 2(a) of the Public Authorities Protection Act 1948 provides that the proceeding shall not lie or be instituted unless it is commenced within thirty-six months after the act, neglect or default complained of, or, in the case of a continuance of injury or damage, within thirty-six months after the ceasing thereof.
The same Act is applied, by section 24B of the Universities and University Colleges Act 1971, to proceedings against a university, its board, senate, officers and employees in respect of acts, neglect or default committed in that capacity. In practical terms, a claim arising from treatment in a public university hospital is commonly approached on the same three-year footing.
The three years run from the act, neglect or default complained of (or from when a continuing injury ceases), not from the date you obtained an expert report. Some secondary writing adds a pre-action notice requirement to section 2. The current official text of section 2 deals with the thirty-six-month period, costs, and tender of amends. It does not, on its face, require a written notice before filing.
How a claim against the Government is framed
A claim about Ministry of Health hospital treatment is typically brought against the Government of Malaysia, and often the doctors concerned, under the Government Proceedings Act 1956. Documents are served in the manner that Act requires, including service on the Attorney General or an officer designated in the Gazette (section 26).
The same Act allows the Government to rely on time limits for suing public authorities (section 38). In a government-hospital case, the three-year period is usually the deadline that has to be watched most closely, because it is shorter than the general six-year period.
When time starts to run
Time runs from the date the cause of action accrued, not from the date you first felt sure that a mistake was made. A cause of action in negligence is complete when the necessary facts exist, including damage. The Court of Appeal in Vista Specialist Eye Center Sdn Bhd v Dato’ Loo Son Yong and another appeal [2016] 5 MLJ 832 considered how to compute limitation in a medical setting. It treated the start date as the date the cause of action arose — when the alleged negligence occurred, or when the damage was suffered.
That is fact-sensitive. In some cases the negligent act and the injury happen on the same day, for example during an operation. In others, damage may appear later. What the cases do not generally do is postpone time until the patient has a full expert explanation of why the injury occurred. If you are counting, the safer approach is to count from the treatment or the injury, and to take advice early if the facts are unusual.
Why a “date of knowledge” rule usually does not help
Patients often ask whether time starts only when they discovered that the treatment may have been negligent. The Limitation (Amendment) Act 2018, in force from 1 September 2019, inserted section 6A into the Limitation Act 1953. Section 6A can give three years from a later “starting date” based on knowledge, subject to a 15-year long-stop. The heading and opening words confine the section to actions for damages for negligence “not involving personal injuries”. A typical medical negligence claim is a personal-injury claim. On the face of the statute, section 6A does not extend time for that kind of claim.
A more limited postponement can apply under section 29 where the action is based on fraud, or the right of action was concealed by fraud. That is not a general rule that time waits until you found out.
When the facts may affect the calculation
Special rules may apply if the injured person was a child, or under another legal disability, when the cause of action accrued. Section 24 of the Limitation Act 1953 extends time in disability cases, subject to its own provisos. How that section interacts with the three-year period in the Public Authorities Protection Act 1948 should be checked against the current authorities, not assumed. Claims after a death, including a dependency claim under the Civil Law Act 1956, can also affect the calculation, and a government-facility claim may still be affected by the three-year period.
Those situations do not change the headline rules — six years for a private facility or doctor, and three years for a government medical facility — but they are why the deadline in a particular matter should be reviewed with a lawyer, rather than counted off a calendar alone.
What to do if time may be running out
Do not wait for a perfect set of records before asking whether time is still available. Keep a simple timeline of the treatment and of any later diagnosis, and take advice early enough for a claim to be issued if that is the proper next step. Only a review of your own dates, the identity of the hospital or clinic, and the documents can produce a reliable calculation.
Sources
- Limitation Act 1953 (Act 254), sections 6(1)(a), 6A, 24 and 29 — official text via Laws of Malaysia.
- Limitation (Amendment) Act 2018 (Act A1566), in force 1 September 2019.
- Public Authorities Protection Act 1948 (Act 198), section 2(a).
- Universities and University Colleges Act 1971 (Act 30), section 24B.
- Government Proceedings Act 1956 (Act 359), sections 26 and 38.
- Vista Specialist Eye Center Sdn Bhd v Dato’ Loo Son Yong and another appeal [2016] 5 MLJ 832 (Court of Appeal).
General information only, not legal advice. This article does not predict the outcome of your matter. Contacting the firm does not create a lawyer–client relationship until we confirm we can act.