Malaysia · 5 minute read

Abul Hassan: why the Multicode criminal case could be tried in Kuala Lumpur

The Court of Appeal rejected a jurisdiction objection but sent the substantive appeal back for determination by another High Court judge.

Financial crimeCourt procedure

At a glance

  • Related financial acts in different locations can give a court territorial jurisdiction.
  • A High Court judge cannot overturn another High Court ruling in the same case as an appellate court would.
  • The Court of Appeal ordered a merits hearing; it did not finally dispose of every challenge to guilt or sentence.

A company-money prosecution crossed state boundaries

The underlying prosecution concerned company funds used in a transaction involving Multicode shares. Abul Hassan Mohamed Rashid and another accused faced a principal securities-fraud allegation and an alternative criminal-breach-of-trust charge. The alternative charge alleged that, as a company director acting as an agent, he had been entrusted with control over company property and committed criminal breach of trust. Paragraphs 2–4 reproduce the charges; the alleged amount on that alternative charge was RM26,045,473.94.

The case was tried in the Kuala Lumpur Sessions Court although parts of the alleged conduct took place in Johor Bahru. The trial court heard the defence, convicted on the alternative charge and sentenced Abul Hassan to six years’ imprisonment: paragraph 5. His challenge to the conviction then became entangled with an objection to the place of trial. The Court of Appeal’s reported decision addressed that objection, not a final evaluation of every substantive complaint about the conviction.

The defence objection and conflicting High Court rulings

Abul Hassan argued that the Sessions Court in Kuala Lumpur lacked local territorial jurisdiction because the offence was committed in Johor Bahru. A High Court judge rejected the objection and directed that the appeal proceed on its merits. When the case moved to another High Court judge, the jurisdiction issue was raised again. Eventually, a Judicial Commissioner accepted it, treated the trial as a nullity and set aside the conviction and sentence without deciding the merits of the appeal.

The prosecution challenged that result. The Court of Appeal identified an important procedural boundary: a judge of the High Court cannot act as an appeal court over another High Court judge’s ruling in the same proceedings. The revisionary powers discussed in the judgment concerned supervision of subordinate courts, not a power to overturn a colleague’s High Court decision. If the earlier ruling was wrong, the appropriate route was to challenge it in the higher appellate court. Paragraphs 31–44 explain why rearguing the point before a judge of equal jurisdiction did not provide that route.

The transaction was not confined to one location

The court also examined the financial transaction itself. The prosecution material described funds released from company fixed deposits and paid through a bank account in Kuala Lumpur for the share acquisition. Paragraph 50 identifies RM17,552,275.20 transferred through that account in connection with the purchase. The court considered that the relevant transaction was completed when payment for the shares was made. Its geographical analysis therefore extended beyond where an instruction or initial step occurred.

The Criminal Procedure Code provides exceptions to the ordinary rule of trial where an offence occurred. The court applied provisions concerning related offences and conduct that takes place partly in different areas or consists of acts in different areas. Paragraphs 47–56 explain why these provisions permitted the Kuala Lumpur trial on the facts presented. A transaction involving several locations cannot necessarily be assigned to only one city by selecting the earliest event in its chronology.

That reasoning was about a court’s authority to hear the prosecution. It did not substitute bank movement for proof of dishonesty. For a criminal-breach-of-trust allegation, the substantive questions about entrusted property and the prohibited dishonest dealing remain different questions from whether the case was heard in a permissible place.

Why a venue issue did not automatically erase the trial

The Court of Appeal gave a further reason. Section 419 of the Criminal Procedure Code prevents a criminal finding, sentence or order being set aside merely because proceedings occurred in the wrong local area, unless the error caused a failure of justice. The court examined the record rather than treating location as an automatic answer. It noted that Abul Hassan had legal representation and had presented a complete defence. Paragraph 60 records the trial’s prosecution and defence evidence and the conclusion that no such failure had been demonstrated.

This does not mean procedural fairness is optional or that every jurisdiction defect can be ignored. The provision addressed the particular local-area problem raised in this case. The court’s reasoning depended on the statutory rule and what had actually occurred in the trial. A claim of prejudice needs to identify how the alleged error affected justice, rather than assuming that use of another courthouse proves the point.

The court additionally examined the historical order relied upon to restrict the Kuala Lumpur Sessions Court’s territory. It found that the order did not assign the asserted limits to that court and considered the statutory consequences of the absence of such an assignment. The judgment also addressed the practice direction for Securities Commission cases. These were additional grounds for rejecting this particular objection, not a statement that geographical rules never matter.

The appeal was sent back, not finally resolved on guilt

The Court of Appeal unanimously allowed the prosecution’s appeal and set aside the Judicial Commissioner’s decision. Its final order was to return the case to the High Court for the appeal to be heard on its merits before another judge: paragraph 73. That last step is essential to an accurate summary. The reported decision removed the procedural basis on which the trial had been nullified; it did not complete the outstanding merits appeal itself.

The six-year term recorded earlier was the trial sentence. This article does not treat it as a fresh sentence imposed by the Court of Appeal or use this procedural judgment to assert a later imprisonment status. The court did not award the company the charged amount as compensation. Company funds mentioned in a charge, a criminal fine payable to the state and damages recoverable through civil proceedings are distinct concepts. No payment or recovery should be inferred merely from the figures in the prosecution narrative.

The judgment requires transaction locations to be tested against the legislation while preserving a separate hearing of the substantive appeal.

Judgment and sources

  1. PP v Abul Hassan Mohamed Rashid — public reported judgment — Paragraphs 1–14, 31–44, 47–60 and 61–73

Plain-language explanations of published Malaysian judgments. Practical guidance is commentary; the original judgment remains the authoritative account of the court’s findings.