At a glance
- Report the condition that explains why a case was withdrawn.
- A correction must address the original misleading impression.
- The original RM300,000 award was reduced to RM150,000 on appeal; payment remains unverified.
One settlement produced another lawsuit
On 19 August 2015, Lim Guan Eng and Shaik Hussein Mydin resolved an earlier defamation action by a consent judgment. Its terms required Shaik Hussein to retract the disputed statements, with Lim withdrawing his action in consequence. The terms were read in open court, and journalists were given the draft consent judgment.
The next day, Berita Harian reported that Lim had withdrawn the suit unconditionally. Lim, then Penang’s Chief Minister, sued the newspaper’s publisher, New Straits Times Press. The issue was not whether proceedings had ended: it was the misleading impression created by leaving out the retraction that explained why they ended. The withdrawn allegation in the earlier case was not established as true by this later judgment.
Why the omitted condition mattered
Lim argued that the report suggested he had abandoned a baseless case and effectively conceded the earlier accusation. The publisher denied that the words carried the pleaded defamatory meanings. The High Court considered the whole report against the actual terms of the consent judgment.
It found the account misleading and defamatory. An unconditional retreat from a claim could give a very different impression from withdrawal following the opponent’s retraction. Accurate fragments did not make the overall message accurate. The judgment illustrates how omission can affect meaning even when an article refers to a real hearing.
Identification and publication were straightforward
The article named Lim, so readers could identify the person concerned. Publication in the newspaper was admitted. The real contest concerned the article’s meaning and whether a defence protected its publication.
This distinction matters for readers assessing their own situation. Being named and feeling aggrieved do not alone establish a claim. The complete communication must convey a legally defamatory meaning, and the court must also address any defence that the publisher can establish. In this case the consent judgment supplied a concrete benchmark against which to test the report.
The publisher’s privilege arguments
The publisher relied on qualified privilege, section 12 of the Defamation Act 1957 and reportage. It argued that court news was a matter of public interest and that the newspaper had acted in good faith. The court accepted the public role of court reporting but required the account to be fair, accurate and contemporaneous.
The report failed that threshold. The journalist had attended the proceedings and received the draft containing the settlement terms. The evidence therefore concerned an available primary document, not an obscure qualification discovered much later.
The section 12 argument also failed because the court found that the publication did not fall within the scheduled categories invoked. This should not be shortened into a claim that Malaysian court reporting has no legal protection. The ruling addressed the specific statutory defence pleaded and this inaccurate report.
Reportage had been pleaded, but neither side pursued submissions on it. The judge treated it as not proceeded with and also explained that the misleading account would not support it. The court further inferred malice from the distortion despite the available consent terms.
Why the later correction did not solve the problem
The newspaper published an erratum on 18 December 2015, about four months after the original article. It argued that it had offered a correction earlier and that exchanges over wording accounted for the delay. Lim disputed the adequacy of what eventually appeared.
The judge examined the actual erratum and found it did not properly correct the published text. It was inadequate to mitigate damages. The lesson is about the content and effectiveness of a correction, not a rule that corrections never matter. A correction needs to address the misleading impression that readers received.
The High Court award and its calculation
On 13 January 2017, the High Court awarded RM300,000 as a combined sum for general and aggravated damages. It did not allocate separate amounts to each category. It considered the seriousness of the implication, Lim’s public standing and the newspaper’s extensive circulation. The calculation was an assessment of the circumstances, not a per-reader or per-word formula.
The original order also specified 5% interest from judgment until payment and RM35,000 costs. Exemplary damages were refused. The court declined to compel publication of an apology by injunction because it considered damages sufficient. A requested remedy should therefore not be described as something the court granted.
The assessment did not provide a numerical weighting for public office, circulation or aggravation. It would therefore be misleading to assign invented percentages to those factors. The later reduction is also a reminder that proving liability and fixing proportionate compensation are separate judicial tasks.
The later award was RM150,000
Bernama’s report of the 12 July 2017 appeal states that the Court of Appeal upheld liability but reduced damages to RM150,000 as the earlier amount was excessive. It made no appellate costs order, with each side bearing its own costs at that stage.
The short report does not establish the final treatment of every original interest or costs provision. This account therefore does not calculate a total balance due. No evidence confirming actual payment was located. RM300,000 describes the original award; RM150,000 describes the reported award after appeal.
A useful check before summarising court news
Obtain the actual order and identify which obligations are linked. A withdrawal, retraction, admission and judicial finding are different events. Preserve the complete article, date, headline and correction alongside the order; a cropped screenshot may hide the qualification that decides the dispute.
This account concerns a 2017 Malaysian decision and its reported appeal. Later cases develop media defences further, so the historical reasoning should not be treated as an exhaustive statement of every protection available today. The enduring practical point is to explain what the court or parties actually decided before compressing it into a headline.
Judgment and sources
- High Court grounds of judgment, 13 January 2017, public reproduction — Paragraphs 4–10 (consent judgment and report), 33–54 (elements), 56–80 (defences), 81–91 (erratum), 95–105 (RM300,000 general/aggravated award, 5% interest, RM35,000 costs, refused relief). Full judgment cross-checked with downloaded reported judgment; public reproduction may limit display.
- Bernama via Utusan Borneo: damages reduced to RM150,000, 13 July 2017 — Opening five paragraphs: Court of Appeal on 12 July 2017 reduced damages from RM300,000 to RM150,000, maintained liability, and made no appellate costs order.
Plain-language explanations of published Malaysian judgments. Practical guidance is commentary; the original judgment remains the authoritative account of the court’s findings.