At a glance
- Take screenshots or snapshots that show the post, the URL, and the date and time. Keep those records somewhere safe.
- Then call a lawyer, and take the copies with you — not only a recollection of what was said.
- Do not reply in anger in the same thread. A heated reply can widen the publication or create a new dispute.
- A defamation claim is about a published statement that lowers a person in the estimation of right-thinking members of society, not about every rude remark.
Screenshots, records, then a lawyer
If someone has posted something untrue about you online, the first steps are practical. Take screenshots or snapshots of the post, including the URL, the date and the time if they are visible. Keep those records somewhere you can find them later, in a form that has not been edited. Then call a lawyer, and take the copies to that conversation.
Posts disappear. Accounts are locked. Groups are deleted. If advice is later needed, the first question is often not “was it unfair?” but “can you prove what was published, when, and to whom?”. A recollection of the wording is a weak substitute for a snapshot that shows the words, the account, the date, the time and the address of the page.
How to capture the post
Take dated screenshots that show the full text, any image or caption, the date and time if visible, the name and URL of the account, and the thread of comments that repeat or add to the allegation. If the post is in a WhatsApp or Telegram group, capture the group name and, so far as you can, who was in it. Do not crop out the date, the time or the address, and do not edit the images.
Where possible, also save the link, and keep a simple note of when you captured the post and who you think has seen it. If you fear the post will be deleted, preservation is urgent. Asking the platform to take it down can still be sensible, but do that after you have a copy, not instead of a copy.
Do not share the post further in order to “get witnesses”. That can widen the publication. If a trusted person can independently witness the page, that is different from forwarding the allegation into a new group.
Do not start by arguing in the comments
The instinct, when a post appears, is to reply at once, tag friends, and demand a deletion. That is understandable. It is not always wise. A reply can draw more readers to the original words. It can also create a fresh publication of your own, which is the subject of the companion article on sharing and forwarding.
Once the post is preserved and you have spoken to a lawyer, there will be time to consider a correction, a takedown request, a letter or a claim. Those decisions are easier to take on a complete record, and harder to unwind if a heated reply has already gone out.
What Malaysian defamation law is looking at
Malaysian defamation law is largely the common law, as modified by the Defamation Act 1957. In outline, a claimant has to show that the defendant published a statement that referred to the claimant and that bore a defamatory meaning — in ordinary language, that it would lower the claimant in the estimation of right-thinking members of society, or expose the claimant to hatred, contempt or ridicule.
Not every insult is defamatory. A crude joke, a sharp review, or an opinion that someone disagrees with may hurt without meeting the legal test. Conversely, a post can be defamatory even if it does not name the person, if readers who know the facts would understand that it refers to that person. The meaning is the meaning of the words in context, including a half-truth. A companion case article on this site, on a WhatsApp message that mentioned a historical charge but not the acquittal, illustrates how an omission can matter.
Publication, in this area of law, means communication to at least one person other than the claimant. A public Facebook post is an obvious publication. A message in a residents’ or parents’ group can also be a publication. Section 3 of the Defamation Act 1957 treats broadcasting as publication in a permanent form for the law of libel and slander. Social-media posts are commonly approached as libel because they are in a lasting, written form, even if the legal analysis in a particular case is for the court.
Correction, takedown, letter, or claim
Not every hurtful post has to become a lawsuit. Sometimes a calm request for a correction or deletion is enough, especially if the author is identifiable and the audience is small. Sometimes the platform’s reporting tools can be used, particularly if the post also breaches the platform’s rules or involves a crime, harassment or a misuse of personal data.
A letter before action, if used, should identify the words, the date, the place of publication, the meaning complained of, and the remedy sought — for example a takedown, an apology, and an undertaking not to repeat the words. Even if words are defamatory, a defendant may seek to justify them as true, or to defend them as fair comment on a matter of public interest, or to rely on privilege. The Defamation Act 1957 contains supporting rules in sections 8, 9, 10 and 11, including the use of an apology in mitigation of damages. Those are reasons to be careful about the facts in any first letter.
A court claim is a later decision. It has costs, time and evidence consequences. If the allegation has reached customers, employers or a professional body, or if it is being repeated, advice on the options should be taken sooner rather than later. People sometimes also ask about a police report. Criminal provisions can apply to certain publications, but they are a different process. A police report is not a substitute for preserving the post, and it does not automatically result in a civil correction.
The first-aid list, in order
Take the screenshots or snapshots, with the URL, the date and the time. Keep the records. Then call a lawyer, and take the copies with you. The companion article explains why a person who forwards the same post can face a claim of their own.
Sources
- Defamation Act 1957 (Act 286), sections 3, 8, 9, 10 and 11 — official text, Laws of Malaysia.
- Common law elements of defamation as applied in Malaysian courts: defamatory meaning, reference, and publication.
- Related case article on this site: Seema Elizabeth Isoy v Tan Sri David Chiu Tat-Cheong [2024] 5 MLRA 68, on a WhatsApp publication and a half-truth.
General information only, not legal advice. This article does not predict the outcome of your matter. Contacting the firm does not create a lawyer–client relationship until we confirm we can act.