At a glance
- Yes — you can be sued for defamation even if you only shared or forwarded the post, because that can be a fresh publication.
- Each communication of a defamatory statement to a new audience can be a separate publication.
- “Someone else wrote it” or “I was only asking people to look it up” does not automatically protect the person who passed the words on.
- If you have already forwarded something, stop further circulation, keep a record of what you sent, and consider a correction in the same channel.
The question people ask too late
Yes. You can be sued for defamation too. Sharing, forwarding or otherwise passing on a post can itself be a publication under the law of defamation, even if you did not write the original words.
A neighbour drops a screenshot into a residents’ group. A colleague forwards a story about a shop. A relative shares a Facebook post “for others to be careful”. Days later, the person named in the post asks who spread it. The person who forwarded it often says, in good faith, “I didn’t write it.”
Under the law of defamation, that may not be the end of the analysis. The law looks at who published the words to someone else. The original author is one publisher. A person who repeats, forwards or otherwise communicates the same allegation can be another.
Publication, and publication again
Malaysian defamation law, built on the common law and the Defamation Act 1957, requires publication of a defamatory statement that refers to the claimant. Publication means communication to a third person. It is not limited to newspapers, and it is not limited to the first person who typed the words.
The long-standing common law rule is that each republication can be a fresh cause of action against the person who republished. Malaysian courts apply that framework to modern messaging. A public share on Facebook, a WhatsApp forward to a group, or a screenshot sent to a new audience is, in principle, a new communication of the words. The precise facts — who sent it, to how many people, with what caption — still matter.
This article does not retell any one decided case as if it were a template for every chat group. A related article on this site discusses a Federal Court decision about a WhatsApp message that omitted an acquittal. That case was about the original message. The principle discussed here is wider: a person who then forwards that kind of message may be making a publication of their own.
Phrases that do not automatically protect a forward
Several everyday phrases are weaker than they sound. “As received, for sharing.” “I’m not sure if this is true.” “Please search it yourself.” “This is just my luahan hati.” An accompanying question mark does not necessarily turn an allegation into a harmless enquiry if the ordinary reader would still take the forwarded words as a statement about the person named.
Good faith is not irrelevant — it can matter to defences, to damages, and to how a request for a correction is received — but innocent motive does not, by itself, erase publication. Justification (truth), fair comment, and privilege are still the main legal defences, and they have to be made out. The Defamation Act 1957, including sections 8 and 9, supplies some of the detailed rules for those defences. Section 7, which deals with an offer of amends for unintentional defamation, is a specific statutory mechanism, not a general excuse for forwarding gossip.
Group administrators and leaving a post up
A person who merely belongs to a group is not automatically liable for every message someone else sends. The analysis can change, however, if a person has control over a page or a group, is notified of a defamatory post, and leaves it up, or invites others to spread it. Those are fact-sensitive questions. Administrators who want to reduce risk should have a simple practice: if a complaint is made, look at the post, keep a copy, and decide promptly whether it should remain visible.
Deleting a post after a complaint is not an admission, in everyday terms, that the allegation was true or untrue. It may simply stop a continuing publication. Keep a copy for your own record before you delete.
If you have already forwarded the post
Stop circulating it. Do not forward it again “so that people can see both sides” unless you have taken advice; that can be another publication. If you can, send a short correction to the same audience, without repeating the original allegation in full. Section 10 of the Defamation Act 1957 allows an apology, in defined circumstances, to be given in evidence later in mitigation of damages. A prompt, unreserved correction in the same channel is often more useful than a long argument.
Preserve what you sent, and what you then wrote to correct it. If you are asked to identify who sent the original post to you, think carefully and take advice if needed. Guessing, or naming the wrong person, can create a new problem.
Platform tools and the law are not the same
Using a platform’s “share” or “forward” button does not give the user a legal immunity that the common law has withheld. The platform’s terms of use, and any immunity or procedure the platform itself may have, are a separate question from the civil liability of the individual who chose to share the words with a new audience.
If the original post is later found to be defamatory, the person who shared it should not assume that the author’s liability will exhaust the claim. A claimant may choose whom to sue. That is one reason to pause before a public share, even when the original post already has many likes.
A habit worth keeping
Before you forward an allegation about an identifiable person, ask whether you know it to be true, whether the audience needs to see it, and whether you would be prepared to stand behind the words if the person named asked you tomorrow. If the answer is uncertain, do not share it. If you are the person named, the companion article sets out first steps for preserving the post and considering a correction or a claim.
Sources
- Defamation Act 1957 (Act 286), sections 3, 7, 8, 9 and 10.
- Common law rule that each republication of a defamatory statement can be a fresh publication by the person who repeats or forwards it, as applied in Malaysian civil claims.
- Related case article on this site: Seema Elizabeth Isoy v Tan Sri David Chiu Tat-Cheong [2024] 5 MLRA 68.
General information only, not legal advice. This article does not predict the outcome of your matter. Contacting the firm does not create a lawyer–client relationship until we confirm we can act.