Articles / Medical negligence
Malaysia · 5 minute read

How do I get my medical records if I think something went wrong?

If a hospital will not release your medical records, the practical path is to instruct a lawyer, who can apply to the court for pre-action discovery or another court order. Do not wait until time for a possible claim may have run out.

Medical recordsCourt orderPre-action discovery

At a glance

  • The practical way to obtain medical records, especially if the hospital does not release them, is through a lawyer.
  • If the hospital will not provide the records, a lawyer can apply to the court — including for pre-action discovery, or for disclosure in an intended or existing claim.
  • Ask early. Time limits for a negligence claim can run while you wait, especially the shorter three-year period that usually applies to government medical facilities.
  • Keep copies of any request and of any records you receive. Do not annotate original papers that may have to be returned.

Obtain the records through a lawyer

If you think something went wrong in your treatment, the medical record is often the first document that has to be understood. The practical way to obtain it is to instruct a lawyer. A lawyer can request the records from the hospital or clinic on your behalf, in writing, and can follow up if the request is ignored or only a short summary is produced.

Where the hospital does not release the records, the next step is a court application. That may be a pre-action discovery application — an application made before a full claim is filed, to obtain documents needed to understand the case — or an application for disclosure in a claim that is already intended or on foot. Which application is suitable depends on the facts, including whether a claim is about to be started and how soon any time limit may expire.

This is general information, not a prediction of any particular order. A court application has to be properly founded, and the hospital will have an opportunity to be heard. The point for a patient is a practical one: do not leave a refused request as an administrative dead end if the record is needed and time may be running.

Why the record matters

The record is the contemporaneous account of what was noted, prescribed, discussed and done. A conversation with the doctor can help, but it is not a substitute for the file. An independent medical reviewer who was not there cannot usefully comment on an empty folder.

Hospitals often distinguish between the medical record and a medical report. The record is the file: notes, charts, investigation results, consent forms, operation notes and similar documents. A report is a prepared narrative, usually by a treating doctor. You may need both. A report can be easier to read; the underlying record is what an independent reviewer will usually want to see. Say clearly what is being requested: a complete copy of the record, including investigation results and imaging reports, and, if needed, a medical report.

If the hospital does not release the records

A written request is often the first formal step. If the hospital still does not release a complete copy, a lawyer can apply to the court. In a pre-action discovery application, the court is asked to order production of documents before a main action is started, so that the patient and the advisers can see what the file contains. In an existing or shortly intended claim, the court can also be asked to order discovery or specific disclosure as part of that case.

Those applications are court processes, with evidence, a hearing and a possible order. They are the usual legal route when a hospital will not release the records voluntarily. They should be considered early enough that a later claim, if one is to be brought, is not prejudiced by delay.

Short context: the file, copies, and access

In a private hospital or clinic, regulation 44(1) of the Private Healthcare Facilities and Services (Private Hospitals and Other Private Healthcare Facilities) Regulations 2006 provides that a patient’s medical record is the property of the private healthcare facility or service. Regulation 44(2) is often read as saying that the record may be taken out of the facility only under a court order. That wording is about the physical file. It does not, fairly read, mean that a copy can never be provided, or that a court application is the only letter anyone may ever write. It does help to explain why, when a facility will not release a copy, a court order is the practical means of compelling production.

The High Court in Nurul Husna Muhammad Hafiz & Anor v Kerajaan Malaysia & Ors [2015] 1 CLJ 825 recognised a qualified right of the patient to access the records, subject to limited exceptions — for example where disclosure could cause serious harm, or would reveal information about another identifiable person that ought not to be released. The decision is also commonly cited for the point that regulation 44(2) is not a barrier to a court order for access. Government hospitals are not organised under the same private-facility regulations and have their own administrative procedures; if those procedures do not produce the record, a lawyer-led court application is still the practical next step.

Do not let time run out while you wait

Time limits for starting a medical negligence claim can run while records are outstanding. As the companion article explains, the usual period is six years against a private hospital or doctor, and three years for a government medical facility. Those periods do not pause merely because a request is pending.

Keep a copy of every request, the date it was sent, and any reply. Store copies of records safely. Do not annotate or alter original papers that are later returned to you. If the hospital will not release the record and time may be running out, treat that delay as a legal problem and take advice promptly.

A practical sequence

First, instruct a lawyer and have the records requested in writing. Second, if the hospital does not release them, consider a court application — pre-action discovery, or disclosure in an intended or existing claim. Third, put the dates in order and watch the limitation period. None of those steps decides whether anyone was negligent. They put you in a position to understand what happened, and to take advice on the documents rather than on memory alone.

Sources

  • Rules of Court 2012, on discovery and related court applications for the production of documents (including applications made before or in the course of a claim). This article describes the process in general terms and does not rest on a single rule number.
  • Private Healthcare Facilities and Services (Private Hospitals and Other Private Healthcare Facilities) Regulations 2006, regulation 44.
  • Nurul Husna Muhammad Hafiz & Anor v Kerajaan Malaysia & Ors [2015] 1 CLJ 825 (High Court).
  • Companion article on this site: “How long do I have to start a medical negligence claim in Malaysia?”.

General information only, not legal advice. This article does not predict the outcome of your matter. Contacting the firm does not create a lawyer–client relationship until we confirm we can act.