At a glance
- Yes, you can file a court case even if the contract contains an arbitration clause. Filing does not, by itself, cancel a valid arbitration agreement.
- The other side can apply to stay the court proceedings and refer the dispute to arbitration, under section 10 of the Arbitration Act 2005.
- If the other side does not object in time, or takes a step in the court case — for example by delivering a defence without reservation — the court case can proceed.
- A statutory CIPAA adjudication of a construction payment dispute can, by section 37 of CIPAA, run alongside arbitration or a court case, subject to the Act.
Yes, you can file — and the other side can stay the case
Yes, a writ or other originating process can usually be sealed even if the contract contains an arbitration clause. The registry is not a filter that reads every clause before accepting a filing. Filing a court case does not, by itself, cancel a valid arbitration agreement.
The more important question is what happens next. The other side can apply to stay the court proceedings in favour of arbitration, under section 10 of the Arbitration Act 2005. If that application is made in time, the court shall stay the case and refer the parties to arbitration, unless the agreement is null and void, inoperative or incapable of being performed.
If the other side does not object — that is, does not apply for a stay — or takes steps in the court case instead, the court case can proceed. “Taking a step” is a technical question, discussed below. In ordinary language: if the opponent allows the court case to go on, or participates in it as the way of resolving the dispute, the court path may remain open.
The stay in section 10 is, in substance, mandatory
Section 10(1) of the Arbitration Act 2005, as substituted in 2011, provides that a court before which proceedings are brought in respect of a matter which is the subject of an arbitration agreement shall, where a party makes an application before taking any other steps in the proceedings, stay those proceedings and refer the parties to arbitration unless it finds that the agreement is null and void, inoperative or incapable of being performed.
The word “shall” matters. After the amendment, the court’s role is not a wide discretion to keep a case because a judge prefers the High Court, or because one party now finds arbitration expensive. The questions are whether there is an arbitration agreement covering the matter, whether the application was made in time, and whether one of the narrow statutory exceptions is made out. The court may, under section 10(2), impose conditions when granting a stay. Section 10(3) allows arbitral proceedings to be commenced or continued, and an award to be made, while the stay issue is pending. Section 10(4) extends the section to an international arbitration even where the seat is not in Malaysia.
If the other side does not object, or takes a step
The stay must be sought before the applicant takes any other step in the court proceedings. Delivering a defence on the merits, without a reservation, is the classic example of a step that can lose the stay. The case law, including more recent appellate discussion of interlocutory requests, looks at whether the act shows an unequivocal intention to participate in the court case as the method of resolving the dispute.
If no stay is applied for, the court case is not automatically struck out merely because the contract contains an arbitration clause. The clause is enforced when a party invokes it in time. Not every letter to the court, and not every request for time, is necessarily a “step”. The distinction is technical and fact-sensitive. It is not a puzzle to be solved after a defence has already been filed. If you are served with a court case and you believe the contract requires arbitration, the stay application should be considered at once, before other formal steps are taken.
When a stay may be refused
The court may refuse a stay if it finds that the arbitration agreement is null and void, inoperative, or incapable of being performed. Those are specific findings, not a general sense that arbitration would be inconvenient. An agreement may be inoperative, for example, if it has been abandoned by both parties, or incapable of being performed if the agreed mechanism cannot in fact be used. Whether a particular clause is too uncertain, or has been superseded, is a question of construction and evidence.
Section 10 does not ask whether the claim is strong, or whether the applicant is a consumer who now regrets the clause. Some other statutes, and some types of dispute, may raise separate arguments about whether a matter is arbitrable at all. Those arguments have to be identified from the subject matter; they are not a general escape from a commercial arbitration clause.
A construction payment dispute is a special case
If the contract is a construction contract to which the Construction Industry Payment and Adjudication Act 2012 applies, a payment dispute may be referred to statutory adjudication even if the same contract also contains an arbitration clause. Section 37 of CIPAA provides that a dispute in respect of payment under a construction contract may be referred concurrently to adjudication, arbitration or the court, and that a reference to arbitration or the court does not, subject to section 37(3), bring the adjudication to an end. An adjudication is terminated if the dispute is settled in writing or finally decided by arbitration or the court.
That is why a subcontractor or consultant may start a CIPAA adjudication for cash flow, while the larger dispute remains headed for arbitration. The two processes are not interchangeable. Adjudication produces a temporarily binding decision, as explained in the CIPAA articles in this batch. Arbitration produces an award on the dispute the parties have referred.
The court is not shut out of every supporting role
Even where the merits are to be arbitrated, a party may still go to the High Court for certain interim measures under section 11 of the Arbitration Act 2005 — for example to preserve assets or evidence, or to maintain the status quo — as the section provides. A stay of the main action is therefore not the same thing as a statement that the courts will never make an order connected with the dispute.
A practical sequence after you are served — or before you file
Read the claim and the contract together. Diary any deadline for a court appearance or a pleading. Before taking a step in the court case, decide whether a section 10 stay will be sought. If you are the party considering a filing, remember that you can file, but that the other side can stay the proceedings unless they do not object or they take steps in the case. If the dispute is also a CIPAA payment claim, do not assume that the arbitration clause forbids you from using that statutory route, or that starting adjudication has, by itself, waived arbitration. Those are questions on the documents, and they should be asked at the beginning, not after a defence has been filed.
Sources
- Arbitration Act 2005 (Act 646), section 10 (as substituted by Act A1395 in 2011), and sections 10(2)–(4) and 11.
- Construction Industry Payment and Adjudication Act 2012 (Act 746), section 37.
- A related case article on this site discusses Tindak Murni Sdn Bhd v Juang Setia Sdn Bhd in the context of a default judgment and an arbitration clause. This article is about the statutory stay itself, not a retelling of that decision.
General information only, not legal advice. This article does not predict the outcome of your matter. Contacting the firm does not create a lawyer–client relationship until we confirm we can act.