At a glance
- Track enforcement status before choosing a statutory stay application.
- A counterclaim asserted in arbitration is not a debt proved by the court.
- Separate each adjudication award, its costs and any actual payment.
Unpaid progress claims on a major project
ASM appointed Econpile for diaphragm wall, piling, earthworks and basement works on a Kuala Lumpur mixed development under a letter of award dated 26 September 2016. The contract price was RM280,000,000. Disagreement developed over performance, delays and payment, with ASM alleging that Econpile had failed to progress the works properly.
The payment dispute included an allegedly under-certified claim and later uncertified progress claims. Econpile used CIPAA, while both parties also initiated arbitration. This created overlapping processes with different purposes: obtaining a presently binding payment decision and finally resolving the contractual account. The existence of the arbitration did not itself answer whether the adjudicated sums had to be paid meanwhile.
Two awards and a much larger disputed counterclaim
The first adjudication and supplementary decision required ASM to pay RM59,767,269.32. The High Court enforced that sum and recorded RM150,000 legal fees and RM203,924.40 adjudication costs. A further adjudication concerning later progress claims produced RM5,959,024.99, which the High Court also enforced. These were adjudication amounts, not a final damages assessment for the whole project.
ASM relied on an arbitration counterclaim of RM276,581,893.96, said to exceed the first award. That figure was ASM's asserted counterclaim, not a finding that Econpile owed it that amount. A reader should not subtract it from the awards and treat the result as the final account. The Federal Court judgment did not conduct that accounting exercise or establish ultimate recovery.
What happened to the stay applications
The High Court rejected the relevant challenges and stay applications. In the first set of appeals, the Court of Appeal left enforcement intact but allowed a stay. The further adjudication generated its own proceedings, and the conflicting practical results reached the Federal Court through appeals by the opposing parties.
The Federal Court allowed Econpile's appeal against the first stay, restored the High Court's decision and dismissed ASM's appeal concerning the other adjudication. It awarded global appeal costs of RM100,000, subject to allocatur, to Econpile. Those appeal costs are separate from the adjudicated principal and the earlier costs recorded in the enforcement proceedings.
The central answer was specific: after an adjudication decision has been enforced as a court order under section 28, it cannot be stayed under section 16(1)(b) of CIPAA. A case summary should retain both parts of that statement: the enforcement stage and the particular statutory power relied on. Omitting either can make the ruling appear broader than the question the court decided.
Why temporary payment still has legal force
CIPAA adjudication is intended to address payment and cash flow while final rights can still be determined elsewhere. Temporary finality does not mean that compliance is optional. If merely commencing arbitration or asserting a large counterclaim automatically stopped payment, the immediate payment function would be undermined.
The Federal Court emphasised the statute's purpose and the absence of a provision authorising this stay after enforcement. It also reiterated the relevance of View Esteem to a proper application under section 16. It did not simply announce that every stay application must fail, nor did it decide all conceivable forms of relief available under every other legal power.
For practical planning, distinguish an application to set aside an adjudication from an application to stay it and from an enforcement application. They seek different orders. A disagreement with the valuation is not, without more, the same as a defect in the adjudicator's jurisdiction or a serious denial of natural justice. The requested relief must match the legal issue and the stage actually reached.
The unresolved account remains a separate question
The judgment does not tell readers that Econpile performed every contractual obligation perfectly. Equally, it does not establish the truth or value of ASM's counterclaim. Those merits were not resolved simply by deciding the statutory stay question. A business may therefore need to plan for an immediate payment obligation while continuing to present its final contractual case.
That distinction also prevents misleading reporting. Do not describe the larger counterclaim as compensation awarded to ASM. Do not describe every amount in the litigation as money already received by Econpile. An order, an outstanding obligation and an actual receipt are separate facts. Subsequent settlement or a final arbitral outcome would need its own reliable evidence before being added to the story.
Where more than one adjudication concerns the same project, keep a separate schedule for each. Identify the progress claims included, the principal decided, interest and costs, the due date, any payments and the relevant court orders. This helps avoid double counting and shows whether a requested order concerns a particular award or the wider contract.
Documents that make an urgent application intelligible
A useful file contains the contract, progress claims, valuation and certification records, adjudication decisions, proof of service, payment records and sealed court orders. Add the arbitration notices and the documents supporting any counterclaim. The counterclaim should be explained through its contractual basis, alleged loss and evidence, not merely its headline size.
Prepare a procedural chronology alongside the account. It should show what has already been decided and which application is now proposed. Econpile illustrates why timing changes the legal analysis: an application cannot be evaluated as though enforcement has not happened when a court order already exists. Early, accurate identification of that stage allows parties to assess their payment exposure and select a legally available response.
Judgment and sources
- Econpile (M) Sdn Bhd v ASM Development (KL) Sdn Bhd & Another Appeal — grounds of judgment — Paras 4–7: RM280m contract, works, certification and arbitration; paras 8–12: first and second awards, enforcement costs, alleged counterclaim; paras 42–51: statutory stay and enforcement; paras 52–54: appeals and RM100,000 global costs.
Plain-language explanations of published Malaysian judgments. Practical guidance is commentary; the original judgment remains the authoritative account of the court’s findings.