At a glance
- Identify the contractual cause of action in the payment claim.
- Separate principal, GST, interest and costs when describing an award.
- A new contractual foundation raises both jurisdiction and fair-hearing questions.
A safety report became a payment dispute
JKP appointed Anas Construction for an apartment project in Jelutong, Penang, under a contract dated 9 April 2015 with a price of RM67,994,500. During the project, Anas engaged independent consultants to report on cracked beams and safety. It later sought reimbursement of their fees through CIPAA after the construction contract had been terminated.
Anas relied on clauses 28, 55 and 56 in its payment and adjudication claims. JKP disputed the claim, including its contractual basis and the deletion of the fees from a revised final draft claim. The adjudicator nevertheless allowed payment by relying on clause 36.6, which was not the contractual cause of action advanced by Anas. The parties were not invited to address that basis before the decision.
The money: claim, tax and the decision later set aside
The payment claim was RM855,074.21, inclusive of 6% GST. The adjudicator awarded RM806,673.78 excluding GST, with 5% annual interest, RM11,070.88 adjudication costs and RM20,000 party-to-party costs. These components are recorded separately in paragraph 10 of the majority judgment. They should not be merged into a supposed final damages award.
The High Court permitted enforcement and rejected JKP's setting-aside application. The Court of Appeal reversed those decisions. A Federal Court majority dismissed Anas's appeals, leaving the adjudication set aside. Thus the earlier award figures describe an unsuccessful adjudication outcome on review, not money proved to have been recovered. The decision does not establish a final assessment of the consultant fees through another forum.
The Federal Court also ordered Anas to pay JKP RM60,000 appeal costs, subject to allocatur. That obligation was separate from the costs in the adjudication that had been set aside.
The majority focused on the dispute actually referred
The majority applied the limits of the adjudicator's jurisdiction under CIPAA. The payment claim and response identify the matters referred; enlarging that jurisdiction requires the parties' written consent. On these facts, the adjudicator did not allow the claim on the contractual provisions Anas had advanced. He selected a different cause of action under clause 36.6.
That was more than choosing different words to explain the same argument. The majority treated the alternative contractual foundation as outside the reference. It also found a denial of natural justice because the parties had no opportunity to make submissions on the basis used to award payment. An opportunity to address an issue matters because a party may explain why the clause does not apply or why its conditions are not satisfied.
The majority did not need to answer the broader questions framed about strict court pleading rules. The practical lesson should therefore remain precise: identify the contractual cause of action and give the opposing party a meaningful opportunity to address a materially different basis. The judgment should not be reduced to a slogan that an adjudicator may never read an unmentioned contract clause.
The dissent explains why the issue was difficult
Mary Lim FCJ dissented. Her approach placed greater emphasis on the payment dispute referred and the contract already before the adjudicator, rather than treating an additional contractual reference as automatically outside jurisdiction. She would have upheld the adjudication. That disagreement helps explain why this was a substantive legal issue and not merely a clerical mistake. She also considered that correspondence forming part of the claim had already invoked clause 36.6, so her disagreement extended to how the record was read.
The binding result was the majority's dismissal of the appeals. A careful article must distinguish that outcome from the dissent's reasoning. For parties preparing an adjudication, the safer practical response is to make the contractual route explicit at the outset and to address any proposed new foundation openly, instead of relying on the adjudicator to repair an unclear case.
Nor does a successful procedural challenge prove that the consultant's work was unnecessary or that the opposing party never owes anything. The court was reviewing the adjudication's lawful scope and fairness. Whether payment can be established through an appropriate, properly framed process remains a different question.
Build a chain from the instruction to the payment right
For a reimbursement claim, collect the instruction or request for the report, the relevant contract provisions, consultant engagement documents, reports, invoices and evidence of the liability incurred. Explain why those documents make the other contracting party responsible. Proving that a report exists is not the same as proving who agreed to bear its cost.
Then connect the amount to the payment mechanism and due date. If a draft final account includes an item and a later version removes it, preserve both versions and the correspondence explaining the change. Do not silently select the favourable version. The adjudicator and respondent need to understand whether removal reflected agreement, a contested valuation or something else.
Keep principal, tax, interest and costs in separate lines. Show the basis for each rather than treating every expense associated with the dispute as part of the construction debt. Anas illustrates how a tax-inclusive demand can differ from the principal awarded. It also shows why costs of pursuing a claim must not be confused with the price of the underlying services.
Responding when a new issue appears
If a different clause becomes material during adjudication, identify what it changes: the factual trigger, responsibility for payment or the measure of the sum. Record the objection or agreement and request a proper opportunity to respond. Where jurisdiction is to be enlarged, consider the statutory written-consent requirement rather than assuming further submissions alone resolve the problem.
This disciplined approach benefits both sides. A claimant gains a clearer explanation of entitlement; a respondent can answer the actual case rather than guess at it. The objective is a payment decision reached within the referred dispute and through a fair process. An urgent cash-flow procedure still depends on those foundations.
Judgment and sources
- Anas Construction Sdn Bhd v JKP Sdn Bhd & Another Appeal — grounds of judgment — Majority paras 3–11: project, claim inclusive of 6% GST, award excluding GST, 5% interest, adjudication costs and party costs; paras 12–14: procedural history; paras 33–38, 47–52: jurisdiction, hearing, dismissal and RM60,000 appeal costs. Dissent paras 104, 133–139, 146–148: alternative interpretation.
Plain-language explanations of published Malaysian judgments. Practical guidance is commentary; the original judgment remains the authoritative account of the court’s findings.