Malaysia · 5 minute read

Martego v Arkitek Meor & Chew: Can Final Architect Fees Go to CIPAA?

Ending an appointment does not necessarily end the right to seek payment for services already provided. The label “final account” did not exclude this claim from CIPAA.

Payment claimsCIPAA adjudicationArbitration

At a glance

  • A final fee claim is not excluded from CIPAA merely because the appointment ended.
  • Show total entitlement, prior payments and the claimed balance separately.
  • Adjudication can coexist with the appropriate final dispute process.

The appointment ended, but the fee dispute remained

Martego engaged Arkitek Meor & Chew for contract administration on a Kuala Lumpur residential development under an appointment dated 22 August 2014. The services included recommending contractors for tender and issuing progress payment certificates after consultation with the client. Martego terminated the appointment on 7 August 2015, and the architect accepted the termination.

What remained was a disagreement over professional fees for services performed before termination. The architect pursued payment through CIPAA. Martego argued that the appointment had ended, the claim was a final claim, and the professional rules provided for arbitration. These objections raised a practical question for consultants and clients: does closing the working relationship also remove the statutory payment route?

The claim and the award were different amounts

The architect claimed RM599,500. The adjudicator awarded RM258,550, recording a total entitlement of RM631,228 less RM372,678 already paid. The subtraction explains the award, but it does not mean the original claim was accepted in full. The judgment's short factual account does not provide a complete item-by-item reconstruction of the fee assessment.

Martego sought to set aside the adjudication decision, while the architect sought enforcement. The High Court rejected the challenge and permitted enforcement; the Court of Appeal upheld that result by a majority. The Federal Court also rejected Martego's appeal. This preserved the adjudication outcome. It did not turn the unpaid fee into compensation for wrongful termination, and it does not establish whether the balance was actually collected.

The Federal Court ordered RM25,000 costs for each appeal to the architect, subject to allocatur fees; these were litigation costs, separate from the fee award.

A final payment can still be a payment dispute

The Federal Court examined the statutory concepts of payment, unpaid party and payment claim. It held that the legislation was not confined to interim claims. Where a sum remains payable for work or services under the construction contract, describing it as the final claim does not itself remove it from CIPAA.

The distinction is between the nature of the entitlement and the stage at which it is claimed. Payment for services already performed may remain outstanding after termination. A demand for compensation for some different wrong requires its own analysis. Putting every loss into a final invoice does not automatically make every item an adjudicable payment claim.

For a consultant, the useful starting point is the appointment's actual fee mechanism. Identify the agreed stages, services completed, invoicing requirements and payment trigger. For a client, the same documents help distinguish fees genuinely earned from work said to be incomplete or outside the agreed scope. The case removes a categorical objection based merely on finality; it does not remove the need to prove the contractual entitlement.

Why arbitration did not exclude adjudication

Martego relied on the dispute mechanism for architects and clients. The Federal Court accepted that arbitration and CIPAA adjudication need not be mutually exclusive. Adjudication supplies a temporarily binding payment determination, while arbitration or litigation can finally resolve the underlying dispute in the appropriate forum.

This matters commercially. A party can have an arguable case on the final account and still face an immediate adjudication obligation. Conversely, obtaining an adjudication decision does not necessarily settle every issue for all time. The payment decision and final determination perform different jobs, so a case summary should identify which process produced each outcome.

The distinction also affects preparation. A payment claim should explain the amount currently due with supporting records. A later final-account dispute may require a wider examination of performance, contractual duties and counterclaims. Parties should coordinate the records used in both processes so that inconsistent schedules, unexplained revisions or missing credits do not obscure the real disagreement.

Making a professional-fee claim understandable

A useful fee schedule begins with the agreed method of remuneration. Where payment depends on a service stage, show the work that satisfies that stage: tender recommendations, correspondence, certificates, meeting records or other relevant deliverables. Connect each invoice to the appointment, rather than relying on a large collection of documents with no explanation of their significance.

Then reconcile the account. List the total entitlement asserted, payments received, credits, disputed deductions and the balance requested. The calculation in Martego illustrates why these are distinct figures. An award smaller than the demand can reflect an assessed entitlement and payment history; the difference alone does not establish dishonesty or poor professional performance.

Termination correspondence is also important. It may identify the cut-off for services and the matters still disputed, but accepting termination should not casually be described as accepting the other side's final account. If the parties reach a separate settlement, preserve its precise terms and evidence of performance. Do not confuse an appointment ending with a negotiated discharge of every accrued payment right.

What clients and consultants should take from the case

Before choosing a procedure, check that the particular appointment and payment dispute fall within CIPAA and consider the applicable dispute clause. Martego is a decision about a qualifying contractual fee claim; it is not a guarantee that every professional invoice can be adjudicated. The work, contract, amount and due date still have to be established.

The practical response to a final fee demand is a reasoned account, supported by the appointment and performance records. A bare objection that the relationship has ended may miss the real issue. Equally, the claimant should separate earned fees from damages and explain the balance clearly. Keeping those categories distinct helps the parties assess payment exposure, prepare any defence and decide what still requires final determination.

Judgment and sources

  1. Martego Sdn Bhd v Arkitek Meor & Chew Sdn Bhd & Another Appeal — grounds of judgment — Para 3.2–3.10: appointment, termination, RM599,500 claim and RM258,550 award calculation; paras 58–61, 67–72: payment and final claims; paras 73–81: arbitration, dismissal and RM25,000 costs per appeal. Award date omitted because paras 3.6 and 3.7 differ.

Plain-language explanations of published Malaysian judgments. Practical guidance is commentary; the original judgment remains the authoritative account of the court’s findings.