Articles / Construction
Malaysia · 5 minute read

The other side has not paid for construction work. What is CIPAA adjudication?

If you are a subcontractor and the main contractor has not paid for work done, CIPAA adjudication is a statutory, relatively quick way to claim that payment. The decision is binding unless it is set aside, the parties settle, or the dispute is finally decided by arbitration or the court.

Subcontractor paymentCIPAA adjudicationMain contractor

At a glance

  • CIPAA gives a subcontractor a statutory, relatively quick route to claim unpaid payment from a main contractor, without waiting for a full lawsuit or arbitration to finish.
  • The Act applies to written construction contracts for work carried out wholly or partly in Malaysia, including many Government contracts, subject to section 3 and any exemption.
  • The adjudicator must decide within 45 working days from the points fixed in section 12, unless the parties agree more time. A late decision is void.
  • The decision can be enforced in the High Court as if it were a High Court judgment, but it is temporarily binding only, in the sense set out in section 13.

When a subcontractor has not been paid

A common problem on Malaysian construction projects is this: the subcontractor has already done the work — and often already paid workers, suppliers and preliminaries — but the main contractor has not paid the certified sum, a progress claim, a variation, or a release of retention. An ordinary lawsuit or a full arbitration can take longer than the cash-flow problem will bear.

Parliament enacted the Construction Industry Payment and Adjudication Act 2012 to facilitate regular and timely payment, to provide a mechanism for speedy dispute resolution through adjudication, and to provide remedies for the recovery of payment. For a subcontractor claiming unpaid payment from a main contractor, CIPAA adjudication is that statutory route.

The Act is not limited to subcontractors. Consultants and other unpaid parties under a written construction contract may also use it, and a main contractor may have its own payment claim further up the chain. This article explains the process through the most familiar example: the subcontractor who has not been paid by the main contractor. Adjudication is built around payment. Defects, extensions of time and final accounts may form part of that payment fight, but the process is not a complete rewriting of the project.

When CIPAA applies — and when it does not

Section 2 provides that the Act applies to every construction contract made in writing relating to construction work carried out wholly or partly within Malaysia, including a construction contract entered into by the Government. “Construction contract” and “construction work” are defined in section 4, and they include construction consultancy contracts. A typical subcontract for work on a project in Malaysia is therefore within the Act, unless an exclusion or exemption applies.

Section 3 is the exclusion that homeowners often need to hear, and that a subcontractor should still check. The Act does not apply to a construction contract entered into by a natural person for any construction work in respect of any building which is less than four storeys high and which is wholly intended for his occupation. A four-storey building is not “less than four storeys”. Whether a building is “wholly intended for his occupation” has been litigated, and it is not always obvious on the facts. The words of section 3 should be applied carefully, rather than assumed to cover every house renovation — or assumed never to matter on a larger project.

Section 40 also allows the Minister, on the recommendation of the AIAC (the former KLRCA), to exempt by order. There is a separate exemption order for certain Government contracts. Neither the section 3 exclusion nor an exemption should be guessed at from a brochure. If CIPAA does not apply, the unpaid subcontractor may still have a contractual claim, a letter of demand, or a court or arbitration path, but not this particular statutory adjudication.

The process, in outline

It begins with a payment claim by the unpaid party — in this example, the subcontractor — then a payment response from the non-paying party, typically the main contractor. Those two documents are explained in more detail in the companion article. After the time for a payment response has expired, either party may refer the dispute to adjudication under section 7. The claimant serves a notice of adjudication; an adjudicator is appointed, including, if needed, by the Director of the AIAC under section 23; and the parties then serve an adjudication claim, a response and, if used, a reply, on the short working-day timetable in sections 9 to 11.

Section 12 requires the adjudicator to decide and deliver the decision within 45 working days from the service of the adjudication response or the reply, whichever is later; or 45 working days from the expiry of the period for the response if none is received; or such further time as the parties agree. A decision that is not made within that period is void. The decision must be in writing and must contain reasons unless the parties dispense with reasons. It must also state the adjudicated amount and the time and manner of payment.

“Temporarily binding” is still binding

Section 13 provides that the adjudication decision is binding unless it is set aside by the High Court on a ground in section 15, the subject matter is settled by a written agreement, or the dispute is finally decided by arbitration or the court. That is why the decision is often described as having temporary finality: the main contractor is meant to pay now, even if a later arbitration or court case may reopen the underlying dispute.

Section 15 is not a full appeal on the merits. The High Court may set the decision aside if it was improperly procured through fraud or bribery, if there has been a denial of natural justice, if the adjudicator has not acted independently or impartially, or if the adjudicator has acted in excess of jurisdiction. Those grounds are narrower than “I disagree with the amount”.

Enforcement, and other remedies in the Act

Section 28 allows a party — including a subcontractor who has an unpaid adjudication decision — to apply to the High Court for an order to enforce the decision as if it is a judgment or order of the High Court. The court may enforce the decision wholly or partly, and may make an order as to interest. Once such an order is made, it may be executed as a High Court judgment is executed.

The Act also provides, in defined circumstances, for suspension or a reduction of the rate of progress if the adjudicated amount is not paid (section 29), and for a direct payment from the principal (section 30) — for example, in some situations, from the employer further up the chain. Those are powerful remedies with their own notice requirements. They should be used only on a careful reading of the sections, not as informal threats.

CIPAA does not cancel the contract’s arbitration clause

Many subcontracts also send disputes to arbitration, including to the AIAC. Section 37 allows a payment dispute to be referred concurrently to adjudication, arbitration or the court. Starting a CIPAA adjudication does not, by itself, end the right to arbitrate, and a reference to arbitration or the court does not, subject to section 37(3), end the adjudication. If the dispute is settled in writing, or finally decided by arbitration or the court, the adjudication is terminated. The two tracks can therefore be used for different purposes: cash flow now, a final account later.

Before a notice of adjudication is served

Check that the subcontract is in writing, that the work is in Malaysia, and that section 3 or an exemption does not take the contract out of the Act. Put the payment claim in order, because the later adjudication will be built on it. The companion article explains what a payment claim and a payment response must contain, and what happens if the main contractor stays silent.

Sources

  • Construction Industry Payment and Adjudication Act 2012 (Act 746), sections 2, 3, 4, 7, 8, 12, 13, 15, 23, 28, 29, 30, 37 and 40. Official text consulted from the AIAC’s published compilation of the Act.
  • Related case articles already on this site discuss Jack-in-Pile (M) Sdn Bhd v Bauer (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd (the application of CIPAA to older contracts) and View Esteem Sdn Bhd v Bina Puri Holdings Bhd (defences in CIPAA). This article is an explainer of the statute, not a retelling of those decisions.

General information only, not legal advice. This article does not predict the outcome of your matter. Contacting the firm does not create a lawyer–client relationship until we confirm we can act.